Alternative MethodsConventional Methods


Neurobiologists Present a New Study – the Wisdom of the Confident
Feb 17, 2021

Reading time 3 min.

The wisdom of crowds breaks down when people are biased. Now researchers have discovered a simple method of removing this bias–just listen to the most confident.

Way back in 1906, the English polymath Francis Galton visited a country fair in which 800 people took part in a contest to guess the weight of a slaughtered ox. After the fair, he collected the guesses and calculated their average which turned out to be 1,208 pounds. To Galton’s surprise, this was within 1 percent of the true weight of 1,198 pounds.

This is one of the earliest examples of a phenomenon that has come to be known as the wisdom of the crowd.

The idea is that the collective opinion of a group of individuals can be better than a single expert opinion.

This phenomenon is commonplace today on websites such as Reddit in which users vote on the importance of particular stories and the most popular are given greater prominence.

However, anyone familiar with Reddit will know that the collective opinion isn’t always wise. In recent years, researchers have spent a significant amount of time and effort teasing apart the factors that make crowds stupid. One important factor turns out to be the way members of a crowd influence each other.

It turns out that if a crowd offers a wide range of independent estimates, then it is more likely to be wise.

But if members of the crowd are influenced in the same way, for example by each other or by some external factor, then they tend to converge on a biased estimate. In this case, the crowd is likely to be stupid.

Today, Gabriel Madirolas and Gonzalo De Polavieja at the Cajal Institute in Madrid, Spain, say they found a way to analyze the answers from a crowd which allows them to remove this kind of bias and so settle on a wiser answer.

The theory behind their work is straightforward. Their idea is that some people are more strongly influenced by additional information than others who are confident in their own opinion. So identifying these more strongly influenced people and separating them from the independent thinkers creates two different groups. The group of independent thinkers is then more likely to give a wise estimate. Or put another way, ignore the wisdom of the crowd in favor of the wisdom of the confident.

So how to identify confident thinkers?

Madirolas and De Polavieja began by studying the data from an earlier set of experiments in which groups of people were given tasks such as to estimate the length of the border between Switzerland and Italy, the correct answer being 734 kilometers.

After one task, some groups were shown the combined estimates of other groups before beginning their second task. These experiments clearly showed how this information biased the answers from these groups in their second tasks.

Madirolas and De Polavieja then set about creating a mathematical model of how individuals incorporate this extra information.

They assume that each person comes to a final estimate based on two pieces of information:

  1. first, their own independent estimate of the length of the border

  2. second, the earlier combined estimate revealed to the group.

Each individual decides on a final estimate depending on the weighting they give to each piece of information.

Those people who are heavily biased give a strong weighting to the additional information whereas people who are confident in their own estimate give a small or zero weighting to the additional information.

Madirolas and De Polavieja then take each person’s behavior and fit it to this model to reveal how independent their thinking has been.

That allows them to divide the groups into independent thinkers and biased thinkers.

Taking the collective opinion of the independent thinkers then gives a much more accurate estimate of the length of the border.

“Our results show that, while a simple operation like the mean, median, or geometric mean of a group may not allow groups to make good estimations, a more complex operation taking into account individuality in the social dynamics can lead to a better collective intelligence,”

they say.

That is an interesting idea that highlights the way bias can destroy the wisdom of a crowd.

What Madirolas and De Polavieja need to do now, of course, is to exploit the wisdom of the confident in some real-world situation.

Might it be possible to create a new generation of social news sites like Reddit which rely on the wisdom of the confident? That’s both possible and a little frightening. Either way, Galton would be fascinated.


Leave your comments / questions for this practitioner

To write a comment please
or
Services
Category filter
Concern filter
Type filter
Sort
 

All categories

Nutritional Therapy
$60 USD
consultation
DNA Life Nutrigenomics, Nutrigenetics & Pharmacogenetics

Overview

This is an initial consultation to advise which of the DNA Life tests would be most suitable to help you personalise you journey to acheive your current health and wellness goals.
DNA Life has been at the forefrone of personalised medicine since…

Kirsty Terry (Msc, BSc, R(Nutr), RTT™, AFMC…
Clinical Hypnosis (Hypnotherapy)
$595 USD
consultation
Rapid Transformational Therapy™ (RTT™) - Remove unwanted habits or behaviours

Overview

Rapid Transformational Therapy™ (RTT™) is a hybrid therapy, that offers unparalleled results; combining the most beneficial principles of Hypnotherapy, NLP, Psychotherapy & Cognitive Behavioural Therapies.

Target audience

RTT™ is about r…

Kirsty Terry (Msc, BSc, R(Nutr), RTT™, AFMC…
Life Coaching
$25 USD
consultation
Consultation & Assessment

*Not sure whether LIFE COACHING is what you really need? Allow me to introduce to you what Life Coaching is and all the benefits it offers with a consultation. Our life assessment will help you analyze where you are in your path with your goals, plans, …

Life Avenue Coaching
Life Coaching
$50 USD
coaching session
Life Coach Services for Adults, Teens, & Children

Overview

…We work with adults that are seeking transformation in their personal or professional life. Other services we provide are customized life coaching and life skill sessions for Teens and Children ages 10(+). My clients do not need therapy or cou…

Life Avenue Coaching

Related Articles

View All
2 min.
Neuropsychology
Mar 29 2018
The Spirituality Hormone

The hormone oxytocin is perhaps best known for its role in feelings of love and social bonding. But a new study suggests it’s involved in feelings of spirituality as well.

The study involved 83 men ages 35 to 64 who received either a dose of oxytocin or …

Vivian Adkins
2 min.
Apr 19 2020
Text Message ~ My Friends, My Family - Life Review {Helping Hands} 💙💚❤️💜

I: I wouldn’t survive this gracefully without God’s Grace. I am so grateful for Father 🙏🏻💙

Earth Angel: That’s the spirit dude. Never give up. 😘 love you dude!

I: I love you too dude! One of my goal is to have a loving community for us and for our futur…

Malyk Yeshua Jason Muqaddar
5 min.
Aromatherapy Massage
Apr 9 2021
Using Correct Topicals for Geriatric Massage Clients

With age come a number of changes.

A session with a trained geriatric massage therapist and the right topical can address a senior client’s needs and also enrich the practitioner.

Know Your Client

Karen Fink, board certified holistic nurse and licensed…

Demi Powell
9 min.
Raw Food Diet
Mar 29 2018
Winning Strategies to Help You Lose Unwanted Belly Fat

When it comes to shedding stubborn belly fat, exercise alone is not the answer. The master key really lies with what you eat, and perhaps more importantly when you eat, followed closely by the type of exercise you engage in.lean

Scheduling your eating to…

Guy Luna