Alternative MethodsConventional Methods


Science Proves that The Wisdom of Crowds Exists
Mar 29, 2018

Priscilla Cain
Core Spirit member since Dec 24, 2020
Reading time less than 1 minute

You just need to find the people that know they are right and expect others to be wrong.

To paraphrase Men In Black’s Agent K, a person is smart, but people are dumb, panicky and dangerous animals. Researchers at MIT and Princeton wanted to see if, despite this, they were able to extract better information from crowds. They appear to have succeeded after developing an algorithm that looks at what people answer, but also what they believe other people will answer too.

As the paper’s authors explain, the democratic method of asking people to choose between two (or more) options isn’t perfect. The system often skews heavily in favor of “shallow, lowest common denominator information at the expense of novel or specialized knowledge.” Hence the idea, so espoused in the UK’s recent referendum to leave the European Union, that the people had grown tired of experts.

In order to combat this, the pair developed a system that essentially gives extra weight to the answers of better-informed people. In the example, a group was given two questions: “Is Philadelphia the capital of Pennsylvania?” and “Will other people think that Philadelphia is the capital of Pennsylvania?”

Now, Philadelphia isn’t the capital city of Pennsylvania, that honor goes to Harrisburg, but Philadelphia is bigger, more populous and better known. But those people who answered no to the first question said yes to the second, showing that they anticipated being in the minority.

The researchers’ solution to polling data is to only select the answer that is more popular than people predict it to be. As MIT News explains, it’s this smaller group that helps give you the proper weight of the overall answers. Put simply, it’s worth looking at those folks who answer against what they believe everyone else will say, since they may be smarter than everyone else.

There’s a sting in this tale, however, because this newfangled algorithm may not be enough to overcome human biases in some fields. At the same time that news of the research was published, the Washington Post carried out a similar experiment with unfortunate results.

The paper asked people to compare images of the National Mall on Jan 20th, 2009 and Jan 20th, 2017 – inauguration day. They were asked, simply, to choose which image displayed more people, and those with a political slant toward the current administration chose the clearly less populous picture. So, while scientists are still trying to make surveys and voting patterns better, they’re still going to have to contend with people being people.

Daniel Coopa/Engadget

Priscilla Cain

Leave your comments / questions for this practitioner

To write a comment please
or
Services
Category filter
Concern filter
Type filter
Sort
 

All categories

Nutritional Therapy
$60 USD
consultation
DNA Life Nutrigenomics, Nutrigenetics & Pharmacogenetics

Overview

This is an initial consultation to advise which of the DNA Life tests would be most suitable to help you personalise you journey to acheive your current health and wellness goals.
DNA Life has been at the forefrone of personalised medicine since…

Kirsty Terry (Msc, BSc, R(Nutr), RTT™, AFMC…
Clinical Hypnosis (Hypnotherapy)
$595 USD
consultation
Rapid Transformational Therapy™ (RTT™) - Remove unwanted habits or behaviours

Overview

Rapid Transformational Therapy™ (RTT™) is a hybrid therapy, that offers unparalleled results; combining the most beneficial principles of Hypnotherapy, NLP, Psychotherapy & Cognitive Behavioural Therapies.

Target audience

RTT™ is about r…

Kirsty Terry (Msc, BSc, R(Nutr), RTT™, AFMC…
Life Coaching
$25 USD
consultation
Consultation & Assessment

*Not sure whether LIFE COACHING is what you really need? Allow me to introduce to you what Life Coaching is and all the benefits it offers with a consultation. Our life assessment will help you analyze where you are in your path with your goals, plans, …

Life Avenue Coaching
Life Coaching
$50 USD
coaching session
Life Coach Services for Adults, Teens, & Children

Overview

…We work with adults that are seeking transformation in their personal or professional life. Other services we provide are customized life coaching and life skill sessions for Teens and Children ages 10(+). My clients do not need therapy or cou…

Life Avenue Coaching

Related Articles

View All
2 min.
Jan 20 2021
5 reasons to match your nutrition and training plan

80% kitchen. 20% gym. It’s a stat you’ll have heard before, but one you probably still struggle to wrap your head around – especially after an hour-long slog on the squat rack. How can all those reps and interval sprints only be responsible for a fifth of…

Core Spirit Ratings
3 min.
Mar 29 2018
Researchers Have Finally Discovered the Key to Naturally Stripping Sugar from All Our Foods

The global sugar-industrial complex is about to face a serious challenge—from a mushroom.

A young start-up based out of Aurora, Colorado is poised to disrupt how sugar is used in packaged goods. Three years after its founding, MycoTechnology is not yet a…

Guy Luna
11 min.
Herbal Medicine (Herbalism)
Mar 17 2021
Swollen Adenoids? Use these home remedies.

Surgery is commonly advocated for swollen adenoids, but you can also try to alleviate the swelling with simple home cures before opting for more invasive treatments. In this article we have listed effective home remedies for swollen adenoids that may ease…

Demi Powell
4 min.
Rune Reading
Jun 7 2021
What is Yggdrasil?

When it comes to discussion of the Runes, a subject which is just as important as the god who first obtained them is the tree from which he hung to do so. Understanding the full symbolic value in a given myth enables one to attain the insight necessary to…

Stacey Gill