Cambridge Science Historian Contemplates Place of Parapsychology
Mar 29, 2018

Grace Armstrong
Core Spirit member since Dec 24, 2020
Reading time 3 min.

In Beyond Science, Epoch Times explores research and accounts related to phenomena and theories that challenge our current knowledge. We delve into ideas that stimulate the imagination and open up new possibilities. Share your thoughts with us on these sometimes controversial topics in the comments section below.

Materialism and psychical research are often viewed as antithetical. But psychic phenomena and the occult have been with us all throughout our development of science, and—like it or not—they have their place in modern science, according to Andreas Sommer.

Sommer is a junior research fellow in the department of history and philosophy of science at Churchill College at Cambridge University in the UK. In April 2016, his article “Are you afraid of the dark? Notes on the psychology of belief in histories of science and the occult,” was published in the European Journal of Psychotherapy and Counselling.

He started out addressing psychotherapists. He asked them to imagine hypothetical situations in which their patients report paranormal experiences—maybe a telepathic connection with a loved one or a profound out-of-body experience.

“In many cases, you may find it advisable not to encourage your client’s belief in the reality of the reported phenomena, while trying to establish what emotional conflicts and issues each experience may represent,” he wrote.

“On the other hand, you might have encountered instances where ostensibly ‘paranormal’ experiences, rather than being inherently unsettling, on the contrary inspired a client’s confidence in higher and ultimately benevolent realities.

“Far from persuading such clients to abandon these apparently irrational and naive beliefs, you may have come to acknowledge that at least some individuals can exploit profound forms of ‘transpersonal’ optimism as highly effective means to cope with, and possibly even overcome, concrete hardships and emotional problems.”

Sommer’s goal is not to prove that psi or parapsychological phenomena exist. He argues instead that the topic of psi has been wrongly marginalized and we must examine it openly.

The idea that parapsychology is unscientific, or pseudoscientific arose in the 19th century from “political, philosophical, and religious concerns rather than scientific work,” he argued. This idea has been perpetuated, in part, due to fear.

He quoted physicist Léon Foucault’s comments on telekinesis: “If I saw a straw moved by the action of my will … I should be terrified. If the influence of mind upon matter does not cease at the surface of the skin, there is no safety left in the world for anyone.”

Sommer qualified: “I don’t want to appear as trying to substitute one crude psychological explanation (‘interest in occult phenomena has been motivated by an irrational need to believe,’ etc.) with another, equally simplistic one (‘opposition to psychical research has been motivated by irrational fears’) and use it as a historiographical argument.”

He continued: “At the same time, once we acknowledge that cultural and personal biases constitute fundamental problems in any realm of human activity, the insight that we have to deal with them somehow seems inescapable.”

What Sommer calls “fuzzy but immensely loaded” words—such as “mysticism” and “superstition”—were used to discredit parapsychology and distance it from the new psychology that developed in the late 19th century.

What Sommer calls ‘fuzzy but immensely loaded’ words—such as ‘mysticism’ and ‘superstition’—were used to discredit parapsychology.

Yet Freudian psychoanalysts were open to extrasensory perception within a materialist tradition, Sommer noted, showing the demarcation between materialism and psychical research was not that clear.

Sommer commented on the emotional, rather than scientific response many scientists have to parapsychological research: “Although instances of violent opposition to new ideas is a commonplace in the history even of orthodox sciences, I cannot help but being struck by the persistent vehemence, the often hateful and emotional nature of some of the attacks that continue to inform this historiography.

“I find myself essentially in agreement with psychoanalyst William Gillespie and many others, who observed that there was a strong tendency among critics to respond to the data of psychical research ‘in an irrational, emotionally determined way.‘”

Sommer concluded: “Frank acknowledgement of the rationalist dilemma must not be confused with an excuse for lazy thinking and arrogant dogmatism. Far from paralysing our critical faculties, its admission might on the contrary motivate us to try harder than ever to identify, accept and eliminate inevitable biases standing in the way of our cultivating benevolent open-mindedness coupled with ‘never-sleeping suspicion of sources of error.‘”

by Tara MacIsaac For The Epoch Times


Leave your comments / questions for this practitioner

To write a comment please
or
Services
Category filter
Concern filter
Type filter
Sort
 

All categories

Clairvoyance
$180 USD
coaching session
Psychic reading from professional clairvoyant

Overview

You will get reading with professional clairvoyant. You will be able to ask anything and everything about your future.

Target audience

If you are looking for answers, what will happen in your future, you should get readings from me.

Benefits

Knowing things about our future is great. We can prepare better for situations that are in front of us.

Session

During session you will get answers on your deepest questions.

Preparation

Just be calm down and relaxed.

Other comments

NostraDamus0806
Clairvoyance
$100 USD
consultation
Psychic reading from professional clairvoyant

Overview

You will get reading with professional clairvoyant. You will be able to ask anything and everything about your future.

Target audience

If you are looking for answers, what will happen in your future, you should get readings from me.

Benefits

Knowing things about our future is great. We can prepare better for situations that are in front of us.

Session

During session you will get answers on your deepest questions.

Preparation

Just be calm down and relaxed.

Other comments

NostraDamus0806
Clairvoyance
$60 USD
consultation
Psyhcic reading with professional clairvoyant

Overview

You will get reading with professional clairvoyant. You will be able to ask anything and everything about your future.

Target audience

If you are looking for answers, what will happen in your future, you should get readings from me.

Benefits

Knowing things about our future is great. We can prepare better for situations that are in front of us.

Session

During session you will get answers on your deepest questions.

Preparation

Just be calm down and relaxed.

Other comments

NostraDamus0806
Psychic Reading
$220 USD
workshop
One Day Psychic Development Course

Have you ever wondered if you are psychic?
Do you find yourself just knowing things and not sure how?
Do you feel as though someone is there protecting you?

On this psychic development course you can explore all these questions and more....

Learn about the types of psychic communication
Learn how to dowse - chakras, flower remedies and food and drink
Learn about auras, and how to read your own or others
Psychometry - learn how to read the energy of objects
Visualisation to meet your guides
7 chakras and how they relate to psychic ability
How to recognise the symbols that you are being given and what they mean to you
Understanding the power of your thoughts and how they affect your goals
Learn how to tune into other people’s energy

And much more....

The courses are run in small groups or one to one. Dates can be arranged to suit you.

Step Into Your Light - Christina Moore

Related Articles

View All
Registered individuals enjoy all the possibilities of Core Spirit.